General Coaching Topics

The Stories We Tell Ourselves - And How to Rewrite Them

August 3, 2025
  •  
5 minute read
  •  
René Sonneveld

Where to listen

Talk with Rene in a

Virtual coffe with Rene
Virtual Coffee

SHARE THIS BLOG

Click the buttons below to share this post

We all carry stories. Some we tell out loud. Others live quietly inside us, shaping how we see ourselves, how we respond to others, and what we believe is possible. These inner stories often start in childhood and evolve over time. Some give us strength. Others hold us back without us even realizing. This blog explores the quiet narratives that guide our lives, the saboteur voices behind them, and how we can begin to rewrite the script.

The most dangerous stories are the ones we do not know we are telling. We repeat them like truth. We build our lives around them. And then we wonder why things feel stuck.

We all carry stories. Some we tell out loud. Others live quietly inside us, shaping how we see ourselves, how we respond to others, and what we believe is possible. These inner stories often start in childhood and evolve over time. Some give us strength. Others hold us back without us even realizing. This blog explores the quiet narratives that guide our lives, the saboteur voices behind them, and how we can begin to rewrite the script.

How Stories Become Beliefs

In his TEDx talk, The Stories We Tell Ourselves, David Mathews recalls childhood moments that crystallized into lifelong assumptions about strength, love, and belonging. His point is simple but profound: the stories we inherit or construct as children become our operating system as adults.

Stella Beckmann echoes this idea, emphasizing how we unknowingly cling to unhelpful scripts. Many of us move through life carrying quiet but powerful beliefs like I am not enough, I do not belong, or things never work out for me. These stories rarely come with a title or a final chapter. Still, they shape everything: how we handle setbacks, how we trust others, what risks we are willing to take.

I have told myself many stories over the years. Some have given me strength, others have held me back. There were stories rooted in fear, in shame, in trying to prove something to the world or to myself. Stories that said I had to always be in control. That vulnerability was weakness. That love had to be earned.

Looking back, some stories stole years from me. I carried shame I did not deserve. I chased validation that never filled me. And I kept telling myself I was being realistic, when in fact I was just afraid.

But that is the thing about stories. We usually do not recognize we are in one until we are exhausted by it. Until it starts costing us relationships, peace of mind, joy. The good news is, once you do see the story, you can begin to change it.

The Types of Stories ThatHold Us Back

Some of these internal narratives are empowering:

  • I am a survivor
  • If I work hard, I will figure it out
  • Life has its ups and downs, and I can handle them

But others are not. Some stories make the world feel unsafe or hopeless. Others shrink our sense of what is possible. And unless we bring these stories into awareness, we keep living by them, editing reality to confirm the plot we have always known.

Here are some of the most common internal stories that quietly sabotage growth and connection:

1. I am not lovable

If you grew up without consistent love, attention, or safety, you may have developed the story that something is wrong with you. Abuse, neglect, or emotional inconsistency in childhood often leave a mark. The story becomes: If I were truly worthy, they would have loved me. That belief does not stay confined to childhood. It shows up later in how you pick partners, how you receive praise, and how you handle intimacy.

You might sabotage relationships that feel too good to betrue or mistrust people who genuinely care. It is not that you do not want love. It is that your story tells you you are not allowed to fully have it.

Saboteur in action: The Judge - The Judge constantly finds faults in you and others, reinforcing the belief that you are unworthy of real love.

2. I am not capable

Maybe you had a learning difference no one diagnosed. Maybe you were criticized for failing instead of being encouraged to learn. The result is a story that you are just not good at things. You stop trying. You assume others are simply smarter or more talented. You might downplay your ambitions or let opportunities pass because deep down you do not believe you could succeed anyway.

Saboteur in action: The Avoider - This voice tells you it is better not to try than to risk failure or disappointment. So you freeze.

3. I never get the creditI deserve

This is the story of the overlooked child. Maybe you grew up in the shadow of a sibling, or with parents who rarely acknowledged your efforts. You learned to hustle for praise and to resent not getting it.

As an adult, you feel under appreciated at work. You are sensitive to criticism and quick to compare yourself to others. Success does not feel like enough. The story says: No one really sees me. And so you keep trying to prove your worth, often to people who will never fully give it.

Saboteur in action: The Hyper-Achiever - You tie your value to accomplishments, needing constant validation to feel okay.

4. Things never work outfor me

This is the classic pessimistic script. The world is against you. You try, but life always finds a way to knock you down. Over time, this story turns into resignation. You stop dreaming. You attract others with the same worldview, and the mutual complaints become a kind of bitter comfort.

Saboteur in action: The Victim - This voice focuses on what is unfair, keeping you trapped in cycles of passivity and self-pity.

5. The shoe always drops

This is the anxious version of the previous story. It is not just that bad things happen. It is that they will, and you must stay onestep ahead. This is common in people with trauma histories. You learn to scan for danger, anticipate betrayal, and plan for the worst.

Saboteur in action: The Controller - You believe that if you are not managing every detail, things will fall apart. Your nervous system is constantly on high alert.

The real trap is not that we have these stories. It is that we believe them without question. We repeat them so often, they start to feel like personality. But they are not who you are. They are just familiar lies with good memories.

Spotting the Saboteurs

Shirzad Chamine, in Positive Intelligence, names these voices Saboteurs because they masquerade as helpful but end up undermining your happiness and effectiveness. In addition to the ones above, others like the Pleaser, the Stickler, or the Restless might also be running parts of your story.

These voices were born to protect you. But if you are still letting them lead your life, they are not protectors anymore. They are prison guards.

Rewriting the Script

Here is the good news. These stories and voices are not permanent. They are not your destiny. Once you see them clearly, you can choose a different path. Chamine calls this the voice of the Sage, your wise, grounded, creative self.

The Sage does not silence the Saboteurs by force. It listens, then chooses another way. It reframes setbacks as learning. It views others with curiosity instead of suspicion. It sees possibility instead of threat.

Start with Reflection

Ask yourself:

  • What is the story I tell myself when something goes wrong?
  • What am I most afraid people will find out about me?
  • Which Saboteur tends to show up in moments of stress?

And then go deeper:

  • What if that story is not true?
  • What if it was true, once, but no longer is?
  • What is a more helpful story I could try believing?

You do not have to leap from I am broken to I am perfect. Amore authentic shift might be: I am learning to feel safe in love, or I do not have to earn my worth through achievements.

Final Thought

The stories we tell ourselves can define us or they canfree us. You are the narrator. If you do not rewrite the story, no one else will. That choice is not comfortable. But it is yours.

I would love to know your opinion on this topic.

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
The Elephant in the Family Room  - Managing the of Legacy Business - Book cover

The Elephant in the Family Room

Packed with actionable insights, The Elephant in the Family Room equips enterprise families with the tools to confront silent threats—unspoken resentments, deep-seated insecurities, lingering fears, and misaligned values—that can quietly erode trust and unity. From power struggles to fractured relationships, this book offers a clear path to bridging generational divides and aligning family and business interests.

Click here to watch the video trailer.